Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Our Responsibility as Writers

by Anna Jones Buttimore
Sherlock Holmes - not a fan of Mormons
My husband served his mission in Russia. On more than one occasion he came across someone who said that they knew something about Mormons and didn't like them. When he asked what they had heard, they referenced the Sherlock Holmes murder mystery, "A Study in Scarlet", in which Mormons are depicted unfavourably.

So let's just clarify that. Here are people living in immediate-post-communist Russia who get their expertise on Mormons from a nineteenth-century English author who had, at the time he read the book, never actually met a Mormon.

As writers, I think we should remember that people believe what they read. Words are very powerful; after all, they are how we learn. Even when you're writing fiction, it's important to check details about your location, history, and anything which is based on reality to make certain that it is honest and accurate.

I'm currently writing a book set in Wales which talks a lot about the landscape, language and traditions. It's possible that there will be readers who know nothing at all about Wales, apart from what they read in my book. So it's my responsibility to make sure I don't say that the weather is always warm, or that there are five times more sheep in Wales than people. (There are actually just three times more sheep than people in Wales.)

Remember, if you write a book about something, then for some reader out there you may be the authority on that subject. After all, you wrote the book on it.


  1. Good to remember! :-)

  2. I laughed when I first read "A Study in Scarlet." Mormons were portrayed so hilariously inaccurately--even pioneer Mormons--I wondered if Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was either just that naive, or if he was just that hateful. But it obviously made an impact on the readers of the time...and, you know, post-Soviet Russia. :)

    BTW, my brother served in Russia, from 96-98...Samara, if I remember right. Where did your husband serve?

  3. Small world! My husband served in St. Petersberg, 1992-1993.

  4. My brother served in Rostov around 96ish. Fun!

  5. Catholics are ALWAYS portrayed as whacko or rigid, or some such thing. It's good to clarify when you can. :-)



Related Posts with Thumbnails